Teo Kok Seong has described the government’s decision to slash the lease renewal premium for the Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall (KLSCAH) from an estimated RM4.67 million to just RM1,000 as shocking and unreasonable.
The National Council of Professors senior fellow questioned how such a drastic reduction could be justified, especially since the original premium had been set based on concrete considerations even after the building was gazetted as a heritage site in 2007.
“The RM4.67 million premium set before the reduction must certainly have had a concrete basis and reasons. In other words, the premium had a valid justification, even after KLSCAH was gazetted as a heritage site in 2007,” he said in a statement on Monday.
Teo further called the RM1,000 premium a rejection, insult and betrayal of the Federal Territories portfolio, which was established in 1979, particularly towards its previous leadership.
He noted that the decision came shortly after a change in leadership overseeing the portfolio, making the scale of the concession even more surprising.
Concerns over explanation and social impact
Teo also questioned the government’s explanation that similar premium reductions had been granted to other heritage sites in Kuala Lumpur, suggesting it was an attempt to deflect criticism over the concession given to KLSCAH.
He warned that the decision was insensitive and could trigger intense public debate, potentially affecting the country’s social harmony.
Beyond the land premium, Teo raised concerns over the language used during the official announcement ceremony. He argued that Bahasa Melayu should have been given priority as it was an official national event organised by the portfolio.
“The announcement ceremony was undoubtedly an official event organised by the portfolio, and indeed an official national event, yet it was found to have sidelined the national identity of the country and the cultural identity of its people,” he said.
He stressed that such incidents continue to recur despite repeated reminders and are disregarded by government agencies themselves. Bahasa Melayu, as the national and official language, must be respected and upheld.
Background to the lease decision
The criticism follows the government’s approval on 14 November of a 99-year lease renewal for KLSCAH at a nominal premium of RM1,000. The decision was announced during the organisation’s 103rd anniversary dinner.
Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh had explained that the land had been gazetted as a heritage building since early 2007, restricting it to institutional and heritage purposes with no commercial value for redevelopment into condominiums or shopping centres.
She said this restriction, together with KLSCAH’s non-profit nature and long history, was taken into account when the valuation committee agreed to reduce the premium. The organisation had applied for special consideration when only eight years remained on the existing lease.
An approval letter dated 1 October set the premium at RM1,000, with the total payment under the official land notice amounting to RM5,011, including the first year’s land rent of RM3,151 and administrative charges.
The Federal Territories Land Committee had earlier approved the surrender and re-alienation of the land for institutional use on 14 September. The move followed Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim’s commitment to give special consideration to preserving the historic building after visiting the premises during Chinese New Year celebrations on 17 February.