The legal battle by 10 sacked Negeri Sembilan executive councillors over the revocation of their appointments came to an abrupt end after they withdrew their suit following reports of Menteri Besar Ismail Lasim’s resignation.
However, the Seremban High Court ordered the 10 assemblymen to pay a total of RM48,000 in legal costs to the respondents.
Justice Ros Mawar Rozain struck out the suit without liberty to file afresh, ordering the plaintiffs to pay RM20,000 each to state secretary Zafir Ibrahim and the Negeri Sembilan government, as well as RM8,000 to the Dewan Keadilan dan Undang (DKU).
‘Litigants are entitled to withdraw, and we will not discourage that,’ she said during online proceedings.
However, the judge expressed concern over the court resources spent hearing numerous urgent applications over the past few months.
Former excos withdraw suit
At the start of today’s proceedings, lawyer Hafarizam Harun, representing the former councillors, informed the court that he had received instructions from his clients to withdraw the suit because it had been overtaken by events.
‘Based on case law, when the menteri besar resigns from office, his executive council members have to go as well,’ he said.
Ros Mawar pointed out that media reports indicated Ismail had not resigned and that he was not a party to the proceedings.
Hafarizam replied that his clients were still awaiting a decree from the ruler concerning the purported resignation.
He also apologised to the judge for notifying the court of the withdrawal only this morning, after writing to the court yesterday to seek another adjournment.
He said he had discussed the matter with the respondents’ lawyers and undertaken that no fresh application would be filed.
On Monday, Ros Mawar granted the 10 assemblymen, comprising eight from Barisan Nasional (BN) and two from Perikatan Nasional (PN), an adjournment until today to allow them to explore the possibility of an amicable settlement with the respondents.
BN said Ismail had resigned as menteri besar on Monday.
Respondents seek assurance against further legal action
Cyrus Das, representing the state secretary, stressed that no further suits should be filed following the withdrawal, including applications for judicial review.
The 10 former executive councillors filed an originating summons at the Seremban High Court on Oct 5, naming the state secretary and state government as respondents.
The DKU was subsequently added as the third respondent after the court allowed its application to intervene.
The respondents had challenged the validity of the originating summons, arguing that the former councillors should have pursued their claims through a judicial review instead.
In their suit, the 10 sought a declaration that the state gazette revoking their appointments was null and void. They also sought damages, including exemplary and aggravated damages.
Dispute over royal authority led to dismissal
The 10 lost their positions after Yang Dipertuan Besar Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir revoked their appointments.
This followed their assertion that his removal in April was legitimate and that Tunku Nadzaruddin Tuanku Ja’afar had become the new ruler.
The palace viewed their actions as inconsistent with their oath of loyalty to the ruler and the royal institution.
Abdul Rashid Ismail and four other lawyers appeared for the state secretary, while Razlan Hadri Zulkifli and Marisa Regina Aris Rizal represented the state government.
Steven Thiru, Shafrin Halim and two other lawyers appeared for the DKU.