Umno cannot expect voters to recognise its governing experience while distancing itself from failures under its own administration, a political analyst says.
Mazlan Ali of Universiti Teknologi Malaysia said blaming individual officials or company directors was insufficient, as senior appointments and major policy decisions fell under the responsibility of ministers from the party.
‘Political accountability differs from legal liability,’ he said.
He said allowing court proceedings to take their course did not absolve the party of its responsibility to acknowledge weaknesses in political oversight and support reforms to prevent similar failures.
Past controversies remain relevant to voters
Citing 1MDB, Tabung Haji and the littoral combat ship (LCS) project, Mazlan said their lasting financial and security implications remained relevant to voters assessing Umno’s ability to govern.
He argued that these were not merely past controversies, as their repercussions continued to affect public finances and national capabilities.
Mazlan said Umno needed to demonstrate genuine renewal rather than rely on its governing experience.
This included giving leaders who were not associated with past controversies greater opportunities to advance and making party elections more transparent.
‘Umno needs to establish a clear policy regarding the suspension or expulsion of members convicted of corruption or abuse of power without political compromise,’ he said.
The party should also support stricter vetting of ministerial and government-linked company appointments, transparent procurement processes and reforms to limit ministerial discretion, he added.
Umno’s contributions should not be overlooked
Meanwhile, Awang Azman Pawi of Universiti Malaya said it would be unfair to reduce Umno’s decades in government to controversies such as Tabung Haji and 1MDB, or allow individual misconduct to define the entire party.
‘We must distinguish between individual wrongdoing, institutional weaknesses and the broader contributions of a political party,’ he said.
He highlighted Umno’s contributions to education, rural development, industrialisation and the establishment of institutions such as Felda and Mara, saying these remained legitimate grounds on which to assess the party’s governing experience.
Awang Azman said accountability standards should apply equally to every administration rather than change according to political convenience.
Nevertheless, he said Umno should not use its contributions to national development as an excuse to avoid explaining weaknesses in governance and oversight.
‘Umno’s historical record remains an asset, provided it can demonstrate that the party has learned from its shortcomings,’ he added.