Reviving the Barisan Alternatif (BA) alliance without DAP could result in a split in Malay votes while driving non-Malay voters towards DAP, an analyst has warned.
Syaza Shukri of the International Islamic University Malaysia said such an arrangement would give PAS little incentive to abandon Umno, which the Islamic party is courting for a political pact ahead of the 16th general election.
She said an alliance with Umno would be more beneficial to PAS, given its potential to secure up to 80% of the Malay vote, as demonstrated by the victories of the Barisan Nasional-Perikatan Nasional (BN-PN) alliance in the Negeri Sembilan and Melaka elections.
Working with PKR under a revived BA would force PAS to compete with Umno-BN for Malay votes once again, she added.
“So the Malay votes will be split, while the non-Malay votes will go to DAP,” she told FMT.
The debate over reviving BA emerged after former Umno Youth chief Khairy Jamaluddin suggested that an alliance involving PKR, PAS and DAP could help Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim counter the political challenge posed by BN-PN.
In the latest episode of the Keluar Sekejap podcast, Khairy said Pakatan Harapan (PH) needed a stronger Malay bloc within the coalition and that PAS could fill the gap.
Co-host Shahril Hamdan, however, said the only way to persuade PAS to join would be to exclude DAP from the alliance.
Syaza said the anti-corruption agenda could provide common ground for reviving BA, noting that it was one of the alliance’s main platforms when it was formed in 1999.
“Right now, both PAS and Anwar are linked to BN, which has corruption scandals of its own. It’s possible they would both distance themselves from BN (because of the scandals) and work together,” she said.
BA was formed in 1999 at the height of the Reformasi movement following Anwar’s sacking as deputy prime minister. It brought together Parti Keadilan Nasional (now PKR), DAP, PAS and Parti Rakyat Malaysia.
Seats and Cabinet positions could attract PAS
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia’s Mazlan Ali said PAS had several reasons to consider working with PH, including the prospect of contesting more Malay-majority seats and securing additional Cabinet positions.
He said an Umno-PAS pact could face difficulties over seat distribution, as both Malay-Muslim parties were likely to target the same constituencies.
However, PAS could secure a larger share of Malay-majority seats by working with Anwar, as PH would be more willing to make way for the Islamic party in those constituencies, he said.
This was because PH had stronger support among urban and progressive voters, Mazlan added.
He also said resolving Kelantan and Terengganu’s oil royalty demands could serve as another incentive for PAS to work with the federal government.
Closer ties with Putrajaya could also help boost development in Kelantan, Terengganu and Kedah.
“Offering oil royalties would definitely attract PAS,” he said.
Two days ago, Amanah communications director Khalid Samad urged PAS, his former party, to consider ending its cooperation with Umno and supporting Anwar’s government instead.
Khalid said Amanah could help facilitate discussions on bringing PAS into the government if the Islamic party was interested in joining the administration.