Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya minority, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruled on Thursday in a historic judgment, ordering the country to facilitate the safe return of refugees and provide compensation.
The ruling marks the first time in the court’s 80-year history that it has determined a state committed genocide. It is also seen as a significant step towards justice for Rohingya victims of Myanmar’s 2017 military crackdown.
“The Republic of the Union of Myanmar has committed genocide against the Rohingya group in northern Rakhine State,” ICJ president Yuji Iwasawa said as he delivered the verdict at the court’s Great Hall of Justice in The Hague.
In Cox’s Bazar, which hosts the world’s largest refugee camp, hundreds of Rohingya refugees watched the proceedings on a giant screen. Many broke down in tears when Iwasawa announced the verdict.
Mohammed Osman, whose parents and four siblings were killed by Myanmar’s military, said the ruling had vindicated the Rohingya community.
“I am overwhelmed … But we have achieved only 50% of what we wanted. We will achieve 100% when we are repatriated with dignity,” the 20-year-old told AFP.
Court details evidence of atrocities
For nearly three hours, Iwasawa outlined evidence of atrocities committed against the predominantly Muslim Rohingya minority during Myanmar’s military campaign, which forced hundreds of thousands to flee across the border into Bangladesh.
Myanmar’s security forces killed thousands of Rohingya civilians and committed widespread sexual violence against women, as well as extreme violence against children, he said.
The ICJ said evidence indicated that around 10,000 people were killed during Myanmar’s so-called clearance operations against the Rohingya community.
It also found that Rohingya villages had been systematically destroyed and replaced with non-Rohingya inhabitants.
The court said the only reasonable inference from the evidence was that Myanmar intended to destroy the Rohingya population, satisfying a key requirement for establishing genocide.
Myanmar ordered to facilitate safe return
The court ordered Myanmar to “allow and facilitate the safe, voluntary, and dignified return to their place of residence” of Rohingya refugees who fled the violence.
United Nations secretary-general Antonio Guterres swiftly called on Myanmar to comply with the order.
The judges also directed Myanmar to investigate and punish those suspected of committing genocide, with compensation to be determined at a later date.
Although ICJ judgments are binding and cannot be appealed, the court has no mechanism to enforce its rulings. It remains uncertain whether Myanmar’s authorities will comply.
The verdict is likely to increase international pressure on Myanmar’s leader Min Aung Hlaing, who commanded the military during the Rohingya crackdown before ousting the elected government of Aung San Suu Kyi in a 2021 coup.
He was installed as civilian president this year following elections that were deeply restricted, as he sought greater international legitimacy.
The ruling has already triggered diplomatic repercussions, with Britain announcing that it would expel Myanmar’s defence attache.
The judgment is also being closely watched by legal experts for its potential implications for another high-profile case before the ICJ concerning allegations that Israel committed genocide in Gaza.
Human Rights Watch senior international justice counsel Maria Elena Vignoli said the ruling provided a significant precedent for victims of genocide and other grave crimes around the world seeking justice.
Gambia brought case under UN genocide convention
The case was brought by The Gambia under the 1948 UN Genocide Convention, which allows any state to take another country to court over suspected breaches of the international agreement established after World War II.
The African nation’s justice minister, Dawda Jallow, told reporters that the verdict was a victory for the Rohingya community, which had endured immense suffering.
“They survived. They testified. And today, they will believe,” he said.
Myanmar has consistently denied committing genocide, arguing that its military operations targeted an insurgency following attacks that killed about a dozen security personnel.
During hearings in January, Myanmar representative Ko Ko Hlaing told judges that the country was not obliged to remain idle while terrorists operated freely.
There was no immediate response from Myanmar’s authorities following Thursday’s ruling.
A Rohingya activist in Yangon said the community was satisfied with the decision but expressed concern about possible repercussions for Rohingya still living in Myanmar.
The activist, who declined to be named for security reasons, said many displaced Rohingya who had fled fighting in Rakhine had moved to Yangon and other parts of the country.
“We hope nothing serious happens,” the activist said.
“Everyone wants to live peacefully. We want the world to prevent any genocide here.”