Pakatan Harapan (PH) should abandon plans for further cooperation with Bersatu following their poor performance in the recent Melaka state election, political analysts say.
Syaza Shukri of the International Islamic University of Malaysia said Bersatu was in no position to compete effectively with the Barisan Nasional-Perikatan Nasional bloc for Malay support.
A PH-Bersatu alliance could also alienate traditional PH voters, she told FMT.
Both Bersatu and Amanah, splinter parties of Umno and PAS respectively, as well as PKR, failed to win any seats in the polls on Saturday.
Bersatu lost all seven Malay-majority seats it contested, while PH secured only four seats, all through DAP, which had opposed the proposed PH-Bersatu pact.
Asrul Sani of political consultancy The Asia Group agreed that Bersatu’s support could be an asset, but said it would not automatically translate into an overall electoral gain for PH.
“PH should put a broader pact on hold unless Bersatu can show that the benefits outweigh the costs to PH’s own standing,” he said.
Cooperation should remain limited
Asrul said any partnership between the two parties should, for now, be confined to cooperation in Parliament, referring to the confidence and supply agreement (CSA) recently signed between Putrajaya and Bersatu.
“Any broader alliance should wait until Bersatu demonstrates tangible electoral value and PH reaches a common position,” he said.
Lack of common ground behind Melaka setback
Commenting on the failure of the PH-Bersatu pact in the Melaka election, Syaza said the proposed alliance had struggled to mobilise voters because the two parties lacked a common cause that could unite their respective supporters.
This contrasted with the Malay-Muslim unity agenda promoted by BN and PN, she said.
Syaza also pointed to distrust of Bersatu among PH supporters.
When opposing the alliance last month, former Melaka DAP chairman Damian Yeo cited Bersatu’s role in the collapse of the PH-led federal and Melaka governments following the Sheraton Move in 2020.
Asrul said the pact’s limited and informal nature had failed to deliver meaningful results for either party in Melaka.
He said a clearer agreement might have improved coordination, but was unlikely to have changed the election outcome.
“Both PH and Bersatu struggled to attract Malay voters, while BN and PN consolidated their support more effectively.
“Their disappointing performance points to a broader problem of voter appeal, alongside weaknesses in coordination,” he added.