Bersama must rethink its approach to identity politics if it hopes to avoid political irrelevance, an analyst says, following the party’s second electoral wipeout this year in yesterday’s Melaka state election.
Ahmad Fauzi Abdul Hamid of Universiti Sains Malaysia said Bersama’s political ideology was out of step with Malaysia’s identity-based politics, which had shaped electoral behaviour since independence.
“Communal identity still dominates the ballot. Identity politics is a constant; it won’t disappear unless we reach a new national consensus that calls for new constitutional arrangements.
“Bersama is living in its own bubble, one free from racial politics, which is too idealistic, at least for the present time,” he told FMT.
Identity politics remains a major electoral factor
Fauzi cited Bersama’s performance in Gadek, where it was defeated by more than 1,000 votes by Putra, a party he described as championing ultra-nationalism.
BN’s S Nadarajah won the seat with 6,472 votes and a majority of 3,514 over PH’s Jegasilan K.
Putra’s Laila Norinda Maon secured 1,317 votes, while Bersama’s B Laveen garnered just 287.
Fauzi said Putra’s nationalist approach appeared to resonate more strongly with voters than Bersama’s liberal platform.
He also said Bersama was in an awkward position because, as a splinter party from PKR, it lacked the influence to attract PH voters despite their broadly liberal outlook.
“Liberals of all races couldn’t afford to ‘waste’ their votes on Bersama since PH is already embattled in its present condition.
“Unless there are special reasons backing a particular Bersama candidate, a rational PH voter would not risk voting for them,” he said.
Fauzi said Bersama needed to incorporate identity politics into its electoral strategy if it hoped to make meaningful progress, including in its plans to contest up to 20 parliamentary seats in the next general election.
“Malaysia’s political system wasn’t designed as a liberal democratic order that some political idealists pretend it to be. Identity politics is a baseline,” he said.
Bersama still building its electoral base
Although Bersama failed to win any seats in Melaka, some of its candidates managed to retain their election deposits.
In Bemban, its candidate Solehin Saleh secured 4,140 votes, finishing second behind incumbent Perikatan Nasional candidate Yadzil Yaakub, who won with 11,881 votes.
Solehin obtained 22.5% of the votes, comfortably exceeding the 12.5% threshold required to retain his deposit.
This marked an improvement from Bersama’s performance in the Johor state election, where all 15 of its candidates lost their deposits.
Before yesterday’s polls, one of Bersama’s key leaders, Wong Chen, said the party aimed to increase its vote share to 12% in Melaka, up from 6% in Johor.
Political consultant Asrul Hadi Abdullah Sani of The Asia Group agreed that the party’s progress should be measured by its share of the vote rather than the number of seats won.
“Bersama is still building its party machinery, so its performance should be assessed by its share of the vote across the seats it contested and whether it is establishing an electoral base.
“Not winning a seat at this stage is not necessarily a setback,” he told FMT.
However, Asrul questioned how long Bersama could rely on its vote share as a measure of progress without translating that support into electoral victories.
“A strong vote share would give it a foundation to keep building, but it will eventually need a credible path to winning seats,” he said.