Analysts warn that MCA could alienate its Chinese voter base if it chooses to align with Perikatan Nasional (PN), which may explain president Wee Ka Siong’s silence on the matter.
Lau Zhe Wei of the International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM) said MCA’s cautious approach reflects its internal political culture, where grassroots support for its leader is uncertain compared with MIC.
“Even if Wee makes a statement, it does not guarantee support from the grassroots. For MCA, removing a president during elections is normal. The safest move is to remain neutral, neither yes nor no,” Lau told FMT.
On September 10, Wee sidestepped questions after PN secretary-general Azmin Ali revealed that MCA and MIC had held talks with the coalition.
Lau noted that unlike MIC, which attended Bersatu’s recent annual assembly, MCA could not openly signal ties with PN.
“They will lose support if they join PN because working with PAS is a problem. PAS’s standing among the Chinese community has been in decline, as the party is seen as too conservative and right-wing. That would destroy MCA,” he said.
IIUM’s Syaza Shukri added that Wee’s evasive remarks reflect MCA’s uncertainty.
“He is being cautious because MCA wants to weigh its options carefully, unlike MIC which seems more decisive,” she said.
She stressed that both MCA and DAP supporters remain wary of PAS, meaning MCA would need to justify such a partnership.
“DAP once partnered with PAS under Pakatan Rakyat in the name of fighting corruption. What will MCA’s common denominator with PAS be?” she asked.
PAS ‘Frightens’ Chinese Voters
Ilham Centre’s Hisomuddin Bakar said PAS’s hardline approach has alienated Chinese voters, preventing PN from gaining significant support from the community.
“MCA knows it will be rejected if it embraces PAS. The grassroots are not ready, and MCA lacks clarity and courage. MIC, however, appears more determined,” he said.
On September 6, MIC deputy youth chief K Kesavan attended Bersatu Youth’s annual assembly, marking the first official invitation extended to MIC, a sign that PN is courting both MIC and MCA.
Asked whether MIC would join PN, Kesavan replied: “That will be up to my party president.”
In June, Wee said MCA’s 191 divisions would discuss the party’s direction at its annual general meeting in November.
