Umno faces little pressure to reform if its ability to attract voter support remains more valuable to potential coalition partners than its record in government, analysts say.
Political analyst Syaza Shukri said stronger grassroots support would give Umno greater bargaining power when negotiating government positions, allowing it to sidestep demands for accountability over its past failures in government.
“At the end of the day, it would be parliamentary leverage,” she said when asked whether Umno’s previous performance in government would influence future Cabinet appointments.
With Malaysia’s political cycles typically lasting only three to five years between elections, establishing good governance for the long term is unlikely to be a priority, she added.
Syaza said Umno had also managed to deflect attempts to hold the party directly responsible for institutional failures, instead attributing them to individuals.
She added that the party’s core supporters appeared willing to overlook its role in those setbacks.
However, she cautioned against dismissing controversies involving 1MDB, Tabung Haji and the littoral combat ship (LCS) project as ‘old issues’.
Syaza also said voters concerned about Umno’s credibility and track record would not necessarily turn to Pakatan Harapan (PH).
They could have similar doubts about PH’s credibility and trustworthiness, she added.
Repeated attacks on Umno by rival parties could also be perceived as politically motivated or vengeful, potentially encouraging its supporters to turn out in greater numbers to demonstrate their backing.
“That will complicate efforts to make governance failures an electoral test,” she said.
Umno could return to power without reform
James Chin of the University of Tasmania offered a more pessimistic assessment, saying Umno could regain power without changing its internal culture if cooperation with PAS proved sufficient to consolidate Malay support.
He noted that Umno had briefly considered reform necessary after its defeat in the 2018 general election, as it sought to return to power.
However, political alliances had since emerged as an alternative route back to government.
“It is not possible for Umno to change,” he said.
Chin argued that the prospect of regaining power through cooperation with PAS had weakened the incentive for substantive internal reform, while divisive political competition had left little room for meaningful accountability.
He added that the rising cost of living and competing demands on voters’ attention could push accountability further down their list of priorities, even if they remained concerned about governance failures.
Political influence must be matched by competence
Awang Azman Pawi of Universiti Malaya offered a different perspective, arguing that parliamentary strength should not be the only measure of a party’s value to a coalition.
He said past failures should not permanently determine a party’s ability to govern.
“Cabinet appointments should certainly reflect competence, integrity and administrative experience rather than the number of parliamentary seats alone,” he said.
Awang Azman said Umno could contribute institutional knowledge, administrative continuity and an understanding of grassroots development needs.
“In coalition politics, parliamentary strength matters, but governing capability is equally important.”
He added that political parties should be given opportunities to change, provided they demonstrated stronger internal accountability and leadership based on integrity and professional competence.
However, Syaza said Umno had already been given an opportunity to demonstrate such changes through its participation in the federal administration under the unity government.
She said acknowledging its own shortcomings, rather than deflecting criticism by highlighting the failures of other parties, would be a starting point for meaningful reform.
Ahmad Zaharuddin Sani Ahmad Sabri of Global Asia Consulting said Zahid might want to keep Pakatan Harapan (PH) as an alternative to secure a more favourable allocation of parliamentary seats for BN.
Azmi Hassan of Akademi Nusantara shared a similar view, saying Zahid’s approach mirrored BN’s strategy during the Melaka state election, when the coalition signalled its willingness to negotiate with both PN and PH.
PH and BN remain partners in the federal government, although BN has joined forces with PN in the Negeri Sembilan and Melaka state governments.
Zaharuddin said Zahid might be seeking to raise BN’s bargaining power following its commanding victories in Johor, Negeri Sembilan and Melaka, although all three states were traditionally Umno strongholds.
BN won 48 seats in Johor while contesting alone. It subsequently joined forces with PN in Negeri Sembilan and Melaka, securing 25 and 24 seats respectively.
Zahid keeping both political options open
Zaharuddin said PAS appeared more eager to finalise an electoral pact with BN for GE16, while Zahid seemed keen to delay any commitment.
“Zahid is playing politics by keeping two doors open: one to PH and one to PN. PH’s presence as a supposed alternative allows Zahid to send an indirect message to PN that BN is not the desperate party.
“And if the allocation of seats isn’t satisfactory to BN, it still has other political options,” he told FMT.
However, Zaharuddin warned that the strategy could undermine voter confidence in Umno, particularly if it creates the perception that the party is placing its own interests above Malay unity.
“Zahid shouldn’t be too confident about his strategy… politics that involve too much manoeuvring and scheming could cause voters to question the true principles of a party’s struggle,” he added.
Following BN’s landslide victory in Melaka, Zahid described PN as the coalition’s ‘new strategic partner’.
However, the following day, the Umno president said BN had no immediate plans to extend its cooperation with PN to GE16.
He said BN and PN would discuss the possibility of an alliance ‘when the time comes’.
PAS information chief Ahmad Fadhli Shaari, however, has called on BN and PN to begin seat negotiations soon.
Seat allocation remains a major obstacle
Azmi said Zahid’s reluctance to commit early to a pact with PN could stem from the difficulty of distributing parliamentary seats, particularly if PAS insists that incumbent MPs should defend their constituencies.
He said such a formula would require BN to make way for PN in many constituencies across almost all states, including Perak, Pahang, Kedah, Perlis, Kelantan, Terengganu, Selangor and Melaka.
This is because PN won more parliamentary seats than BN in these states in the 2022 general election, effectively wiping Umno out in Kedah, Perlis, Kelantan and Terengganu.