Former Umno leader Puad Zarkashi has warned that Bersama risks suffering the same political fate as Muda and Pejuang if it insists on going solo in future elections, including the 16th general election (GE16).
Puad said Bersama could not rely solely on the influence of former PKR deputy president Rafizi Ramli, but needed to strengthen its grassroots network and seek alliances with other parties to expand its political influence.
‘Bersama is currently dependent on Rafizi alone. It will end up like Muda and Pejuang. In the end, it will be forced to look for alliances,’ he said in a Facebook post following the party’s wipeout in Saturday’s Melaka state election.
All 16 Bersama candidates were defeated in the election, although its candidate in Bemban, Solehin Saleh, managed to retain his deposit.
The party comprises mainly former PKR leaders, including Rafizi, Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad, Wong Chen and Lee Chean Chung.
Muda has contested seats in several state elections alongside Parti Sosialis Malaysia, while refusing to join a broader coalition. However, it has failed to establish itself as a formidable challenger.
It currently holds only the Muar parliamentary seat through Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman, who retained it in the 2022 general election (GE15) under an electoral pact with Pakatan Harapan (PH).
Similarly, Pejuang contested several state elections independently but failed to win a single seat. It also led the Gerakan Tanah Air coalition in GE15, in which all its candidates lost their deposits.
The party currently has no parliamentary seats but joined Perikatan Nasional in June.
Bersama struggling to win over voters
Puad said Bersama appeared to lack ideas capable of capturing voters’ hearts and minds, questioning whether it could expand its presence if it refused to accept Malaysia’s political realities.
The former MP also questioned Rafizi’s position that Bersama was not established to secure immediate electoral victories, but rather to challenge identity politics.
‘It’s very difficult to go solo in Malaysia’s context. You have to look for a partner, which are all involved in identity politics. If Bersama is too idealistic, it might close shop earlier than expected.
‘Rafizi needs to learn to be a leader who doesn’t think he knows it all,’ Puad added.