Pakatan Harapan’s (PH) failure to understand the Malay electorate contributed to its poor performance in the Melaka state election, despite the federal government’s efforts to raise wages and create job opportunities, political observers say.
Speaking at a forum discussing the Nov 14 polls, Ilham Centre CEO Hisommudin Bakar said Umno candidates had spent the past four years building close relationships with voters, becoming so familiar with their constituents that they could ‘even enter their kitchens’.
PH, on the other hand, focused on fighting corruption and promoting good governance, issues which he said were disconnected from the everyday concerns of ordinary voters at the grassroots level.
‘PH made grand promises that were far removed from the hearts of Malay voters. What they wanted was the politics of goodwill,’ he said, adding that Umno understood this and had established strong relationships between its local representatives and constituents.
Barisan Nasional (BN) won 21 of the 28 state assembly seats in the election, while PH secured four and Perikatan Nasional (PN) took three.
Hisommudin said PH’s anti-corruption narrative largely appealed to its existing supporters but failed to resonate with undecided voters.
Even the federal budget was too abstract for ordinary voters, he said, contrasting it with former prime minister Muhyiddin Yassin’s ‘Makcik Kiah’ narrative during the Covid-19 pandemic, which was easier for the public to relate to.
BN and PN focused on simple campaign messages
Media practitioner Nazri Kahar said BN and PN had relied on two consistent campaign messages: Malay-Muslim unity and the perceived threat posed by DAP.
‘The messages were easily understood. People did not have to think too much,’ he said.
‘People voted based on what they received, what they saw and what they felt.’
Hisommudin said weaknesses in PH’s election machinery were already apparent from the first day of campaigning.
In contrast, cooperation between BN and PN had been built through religious and community networks long before polling day.
‘Anwar delivers, BN gets the credit’
Nazri said that although Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim’s administration had spent billions of ringgit on Sumbangan Tunai Rahmah (STR) and Sumbangan Asas Rahmah (SARA) assistance, BN managed to earn political goodwill simply by distributing food baskets.
‘These people interact with the rakyat every day,’ he said, referring to BN’s grassroots workers.
Academic Abdul Muqit Muhammad said public satisfaction with Anwar’s leadership did not necessarily translate into votes for PH.
He noted that despite Anwar’s frequent engagements with religious scholars, the impact of these efforts was not reaching local communities.
Hisommudin said PH’s difficulties in attracting Malay voters had historical roots, noting that Anwar’s political movement had previously relied on PAS to bring in Malay support.
Bersatu had played a similar role in helping PH secure victory in the 2018 general election, he said.
With neither party now part of PH, the coalition faces the challenge of securing sufficient Malay support on its own.
Hisommudin also cautioned PH against taking its traditional supporters for granted, pointing to a decline in Indian voter support in Melaka from about 55% to 56% in 2021 to 46% in Saturday’s election.
‘The Indian voters did not send a good signal to PH,’ he said.