Umno may be prepared to sacrifice Ismail Lasim as Negeri Sembilan menteri besar to preserve its hold on the state government, but the handling of his purported resignation could create a trust deficit within the party, analysts say.
Azmi Hassan of Akademi Nusantara said Ismail’s withdrawal from the post appeared to be a possible way to resolve Umno’s standoff with the palace while allowing Barisan Nasional (BN) to remain in power.
‘I see Umno taking steps to sacrifice Ismail Lasim as menteri besar,’ he told FMT.
However, Ahmad Zaharuddin Sani Ahmad Sabri of Global Asia Consulting warned that the episode could undermine trust between Umno’s top leadership and its lower-ranking leaders.
He said party members could begin questioning the need to remain loyal if following the leadership’s decisions meant they could ultimately be left to bear the consequences.
‘If someone who has consistently followed party decisions can end up in such a predicament without a convincing explanation, what assurance is there that the same will not happen to other leaders?’ he said.
Questions over Ismail’s resignation
His warning followed claims by Ismail’s son, Naim, that his father was being made a scapegoat for the political crisis in Negeri Sembilan.
Responding to Naim’s questions about whether Ismail had actually resigned, Umno president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi said his decision to step down was voluntary and had not been made on the party’s instructions.
Zahid also criticised Naim for interfering in matters concerning state administration.
BN secretary-general Zambry Abd Kadir announced Ismail’s resignation on Nov 16.
However, the Negeri Sembilan palace said the following day that it had yet to verify the authenticity of the resignation letter, adding that Ismail’s departure from office was subject to the ruler’s consent.
Ismail remained menteri besar on Nov 18 after an audience with Yang di-Pertuan Besar Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir the previous day.
Zaharuddin said Naim’s allegations warranted an explanation from Umno’s national leadership.
‘If he was merely carrying out instructions, the leadership must explain who made the decisions and who should be held responsible,’ he said.
He added that party leaders should not be expected to share the credit when things went well but shoulder the blame alone when problems arose.
Constitutional process and royal consent
Zaharuddin said the handling of the resignation had also raised questions about whether political decisions had bypassed the proper constitutional process.
He stressed that a party’s authority over its members did not replace the constitutional procedures governing the appointment and departure of a menteri besar.
‘The palace is not the party secretary-general’s office, and royal consent is not merely a formality to legitimise political decisions that have already been announced,’ he said.
The dispute with the palace stemmed from Ismail’s endorsement in September of a statement by the state’s newly sworn-in executive council affirming Tuanku Muhriz’s purported removal as ruler.
Following the move, the ruler revoked the appointments of all 10 state executive council members.
On Nov 18, Zambry urged all parties to allow the process to take its course.
‘I do not want to make any statements that might be misunderstood again,’ he said.
Zaharuddin said Ismail should be given room to explain his position, but describing the resignation as voluntary did not absolve the party leadership of responsibility for explaining its earlier announcement.
‘A statement by the president is no substitute for transparency,’ he said.
He warned that perceived injustices arising from decisions made by Umno’s supreme council could cause disappointment among grassroots leaders.
‘What is more dangerous for Umno is not losing a menteri besar, but potentially losing the trust of leaders within the party,’ he said.